Smitten kitchen banana bread review.

Smitten kitchen banana bread cake is simple to make. Bananas, which should be exceptionally ripe, are an absolute must, as are the other baking basics. Traditionally, smitten kitchen banana bread is a butter cake with the addition of mashed banana to enhance the flavor. Compared to banana cake, banana bread has a more complex, more solid texture, ideal for toasting and cutting into slices. Deb Perelman of the Smitten Kitchen is one of my favorite food bloggers and cookbook authors. This article will discuss more different types of Smitten kitchen banana bread.

Favorite banana bread recipes:

Ideally, it should be something distinctive enough to be remembered but not so complicated that it requires a trip to the grocery store for completion. We invited you to contribute your favorite banana bread recipes through an Instagram poll, and then we placed the four most popular responses against one another in a recipe battle. Sometimes these conflicts are more about gleaning valuable suggestions and approaches from recipes than discovering a single flawless dish.

The recipe for the best banana bread:

It has a strong banana taste and a caramel-brown crust, and yes, I will give bonus points if the crust includes a crunchy sugar topping. It is the ultimate banana bread. Ideally, banana bread should be moist and supple while retaining a solid slice when cut into slices. It is also considered how well the bread will stand up to being toasted the following morning. Finally, banana bread should be simple to create and need the use of just a few items.

Four well-known banana bread recipes:

Except for Chrissy Teigen’s smitten kitchen banana bread, which asks for a Bundt pan, I cooked all loaves in the same oven and the same conventional loaf pan. The bananas were sourced from two enormous bunches acquired on the same day and left to mature in the exact location.

Smitten Kitchen’s Banana Bread:

Large mixing bowl: Mash three to four ripe bananas with salted butter until smooth and creamy. Brown sugar, an egg, vanilla extract, whiskey, cinnamon, nutmeg, and crushed cloves are all added. Sprinkle the baking soda and salt over the wet banana mixture, then gradually fold in the flour until everything is well combined. Bake until a cake tester comes out clean and the top is golden brown, about 30 minutes.

Receives an Unvarnished Review:

That’s what I thought when I made this banana bread. One dish is all that is needed to make this “jacked-up” loaf, which is laced with bourbon and studded with cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. It may be the winner. In contrast to the other banana bread in this bake-off, which needs two eggs per loaf, Smitten Kitchen’s recipe asks for one egg for each loaf.

Variety of sugar:

The recipe from Smitten Kitchen asks for three to four bananas, which I enjoy since you never know how many bananas you’ll have sitting on your counter at any one time. Deb’s proposal in the headnotes led me to pick four as a starting point. A variety of sugar is also provided, apparently because the sweetness of bananas is closely related to how ripe they are at the time of preparation. The bread’s structural integrity might be enhanced by adding another egg.

Muffin-mixing process:

The standard muffin-mixing process asks for combining the dry components in one dish and the wet ones in another and then swirling them together until they are barely blended. However, it is relatively uncommon to combine quick-smitten kitchen banana bread and cakes in a single pot, as in this recipe. The crumb of one-bowl quick bread may still be moist and soft as long as the ingredients are carefully blended without being over-mixed.

A sprinkle of salt:

However, the suggestion to sprinkle the salt and baking soda over the banana mixture before adding the flour was ordinary. It may have resulted in the leavening action being triggered too soon. As a consequence, the bread is thick and heavy in texture.

Spicy perfume:

While the banana bread was baking, a sweet and spicy perfume filled the air in my kitchen. Despite a hefty dose of cinnamon, the aromas of nutmeg and bourbon came through. However, the issue was not with the taste of the bread but rather with the loaf’s texture. Even though it had several of my favorite ingredients, this bread was at the bottom of my list.

The recipe you pick:

No matter the recipe you pick, include your favorite flavorings. A better way to use up the spices and bourbon in your pantry than to liven up a simple morning bread recipe. The spices used in this recipe provide a deep, spicy scent to the bread without overpowering the sweetness of the bananas in the batter. This banana bread receives high marks for its simplicity of construction and taste, but it receives a hefty deficiency for its thick texture, which no amount of toasting could alleviate.


If you want more excellent distribution and lift, whisk together the baking soda and salt before adding the flour instead of sprinkling them on top of the banana mixture before adding the flour. Add one additional egg to the mix. There was a solid texture to this bread, and it was also the squattest of the five. Adding a second egg, for a total of two eggs, may help to enhance the structure of the banana bread and sustain the added height of the smitten kitchen banana bread.


What is causing my banana bread to be so dry?

When it comes to banana bread, moisture is essential, and the proportion of wheat to banana makes all the difference.

What is causing my banana bread to be thick and flat?

To make a yeast-risen loaf that’s chewy and delicate like banana bread, you’ll need to whisk your banana bread batter a lot more than you need to to get a dense, spongy loaf. You’ll get a dense, chewy loaf of banana bread if you overmix the batter.

When the banana bread is finished, what temperature should it be?

When the middle of the bread has been cooked through, a thermometer will read between 200°F and 205°F in the center of the loaf.